Monday, October 26, 2009

You Only Live Twice?



I was going to write my next blog on the virtues of high-speed rail and why it will be the best thing for Florida since the advent of air conditioning, but while trying to think about how not to bore you with endless prose, I came across something that broke my heart: according to Ballpark Digest, Al Lang Field is now considered the most endangered ballpark in the country. What does that mean? It means the piece of property credited with starting the modern incarnation of Spring Training will, unless something is done quickly, become nothing more than another park.

Don't get me wrong, I'm a huge fan of the St. Petersburg waterfront. I believe the idea of leaving the waterfront parkland in perpetuity took tremendous foresight by the city's founders, especially in a time when the only true sign of a "major city" was factories billowing with smoke and water browner than mud. "It's a minor inconvenience to becoming a modern city," was the common contemporary thinking, and not to kowtow to that was incredible. Mayor Al Lang, for whom the current stadium is named, thought that, instead of trying to become an industrial powerhouse, get the teams of the northern metropolises to come to him. He then took a piece of that parkland and built a stadium on what is the parking lot of the current stadium and built Waterfront Park to replace his first brainchild, Coffee Pot Park, opened just 10 years earlier.

Everyone from Babe Ruth to Joe DiMaggio, and Stan Musial to Ozzie Smith, all played on this hallowed ground every March. A total of seven teams called this price of property bounded by 1st St S, 1st Ave SE, Bayshore Dr SE, and 4th Ave SE, home over the course of 86 years. With the left foul line a mere 100 feet from Tampa Bay and Albert Whitted Airport's 7/25 runway about 1000 feet from the outfield wall, its scenery is easily number one in the Grapefruit League, and quite possibly one of the best in the country. While there is no outfield seating (like most Spring Training ballparks in the Sunshine State), the berms along the foul lines are very comfortable and oriented perfectly fine for viewing baseball. But alas, at the close of Rays Spring Training in 2008, the bats have fallen silent.

There are many theories as to why it sits idle today, but what everyone can agree on one thing: the Rays left for Port Charlotte in March of this year for a new spring home. My theory is this: yes, they wanted a new pro stadium on the site, and to me, it seems like the natural progression from Minor League host city to Major League Player. However, a majority of the city thought differently, and the Rays are now looking elsewhere - be it in Tropicana Field's parking lot or Tampa - so the shell of the former icon sits mothballed, hoping to one day have a game played. So, it still sits empty, but with all the amenities I've explained, why would that be? It's because the seating area itself is outdated and not conducive to attracting another homeless team (like the Cubs, who just told Mesa, AZ, to give them a new home ASAP, or they're leaving HoHoKam Park at the end of next Spring Training. Hey, Mayor Baker, you reading this?!?), despite everything going for it. No matter how beautiful the locale, no one wants to play in a dump.

The best thing the city can do is the following: tear down Al Lang Field as it is today. Turn the grandstand to where the outfield is today and orient home plate to face due north; that, right there, will get the sun out of the batter's eyes, plus give everyone in the seats the most spectacular downtown skyline view of almost any ballpark (what park do you know is a block from the city's tallest buildings?). Build outfield seating, even if it's just a berm with a boardwalk that raps around the entire structure, thus expanding seating. Recruit local restaurants to provide the concessions, giving the fare a distinctively St. Pete feel. Finally, bring Minor League Baseball back. While the biggest draw will be March and Spring Training, people like me who love baseball, while still going to Rays games religiously, would want to take in a Saturday night ballgame on a day when the Rays are out of town; they could easily work out a schedule that wouldn't conflict too much between the two organizations, even if they are separate teams. Just don't let it disappear.

The current mayoral race here in St. Petersburg has a lot riding on it. The two candidates are differing on many key issues, from policing to how to handle a new stadium for the Rays. However, what has never been brought up in the debates is how they will handle Al Lang Field. I recently e-mailed both candidates for mayor and asked what they intend to do with sacred ground. Bill Foster plans to have an "Asian Major League" team train here alongside the MLB (which makes sense since the Grapefruit League now only has 15 members with the departure of the Reds for Goodyear, AZ, this coming year), and having Canadian and European teams fill the rest of the year. As he told me in an e-mail from 10/15:
"I am already working on this, and have great interest from a major league team from Korea, and the Canadian National team is already on board. Once Korea comes on board, a team from Japan can't be too far behind."
This could be a promising - and interesting - idea. My only question is how many people will actually come to Florida from Korea in March, and how many Canadians will actually come down in the heat of August? Getting anyone that's never heard of St. Pete to come is always a plus, but how realistic is that of an expectation? I'm open to new ideas, but I think we should get the guaranteed money in first before expanding globally. Definitely intriguing, though.

I have yet to hear back from Kathleen Ford's camp. The e-mail to both was sent out on 10/15. If she responds I'll update this post accordingly, but as of this moment, I have to take this as she is too focused on forcing the Rays into keeping the Trop until 2027 instead of worrying about things in her own backyard that can be solved today. I'm open to a future without Al Lang Field, the ballpark, if a reasonable alternative is presented. However, another open-space park is not one of them.

(10/30 UPDATE: She finally responded! See the info HERE!!!)

The loss of an icon, or a rebirth? That all depends on who you ask or what happens in the near future. Even if you don't like baseball, you need to be able to respect the land for what it has come to represent: the beginning of a springtime ritual that has thousands migrate south for 30 days of pleasure. While times have changed, Spring Training has not, and it's all based on the formula perfected on this plot of land by the small sleepy town of St. Pete. Just as St. Pete has grown into the 4th-largest city in Florida, has it truly outgrown its roots that much? I don't believe so, but I hope the the rest of the city feels the same way. Otherwise, another piece of our history will be reduced to a lawn.

2 comments:

  1. And then there is that....
    Alright, firstly, I don't think Mayor Baker actually read this article. Secondly, why didn't Kathy Ford resond? Thirdly, why would you want to re-orient the field? If you could see the water and the bay, why would you want to see some buildings instead? Isn't the whole big deal over WATERFRONT property, not building-front property?

    Anyway, I would say if you like the "history" and "culture" of St. Pete, than don't tear it down. Spend the money it takes to refurbish the stadium, giving it a down-home feel that has some flair, but at the same time, a touch of the old-days, and sell the idea...it could be really popular. Maybe even include a bit of a museum of the history of the site and make it a landmark.

    Either way, there isn't any point in any of this if they can't secure a team at the sight. Otherwise, you might as well turn it into a park, atleast that way it'll get some use.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well, I doubt he'll read it, either, but stranger things have happened, that's for sure.

    I haven't the slightest idea why Ms. Ford hasn't gotten back to me either, but you're free to e-mail her yourself to ask her why: kathleenformayor@gmail.com If/when you find out, could you let me know why, please?

    See, if you flip it 180°, not only will you get the water and planes landing, but you'll get the buildings, too. I'm not saying it currently has a terrible view; in fact, it's just the opposite. I think, however, a simple change like that with new amenities (a la Bright House Field or Charlotte Sports Park) would boost the ambiance and overall feel of the park tremendously and enhance its strong points tenfold. The investment would more than be made up in the return.

    A new ballpark (I hate the word "stadium" for something as small as any Minor League-grade park) wouldn't be the goal, it would be rehabbing the current one. It'd still be the same playing field, just reoriented, and it'd still be the same plot of land. The grandstand is from the 70s, and even then, it wasn't cutting-edge. Like you were talking about certain movies, the stands haven't aged well. But I really like the idea of the museum. Since MiLB's corporate headquarters moved from the tiny building on Al Lang's property to north St. Pete near Gandy, that would be the perfect place to build some sort of historical society/museum dedicated to baseball in Tampa Bay. Awesome idea!

    I see your point of saving an empty lot (though I disagree with the theory of "if no one's there, tear it down", since Charlotte Sports Park was empty for 8 years, but it has new life again), but if it needs to come down to be more "usable", why not build a museum dedicated to the history of the land, and Tampa Bay's sports history in general? Why does it need to be another lawn from which the homeless to be chased? It seems like a waste of taxpayer money to do that, especially with the new DalĂ­ and the Mahaffey right next door.

    ReplyDelete